AN INTERROGATION OF THE "REAL" IN ALL ITS GUISES
Hamm: What's happening?
Clov: Something is taking its course.
Beckett
Thursday, 20 October 2022
Greater things
Monday, 10 December 2018
Áve
Hail Mary, full of grace,
the Lord is with thee.
Blessed art thou amongst women,
and blessed is the fruit of thy womb, Jesus.
Holy Mary, Mother of God,
pray for us sinners,
now and at the hour of our death. Amen."
With the Holy Spirit and Power
Your voice echoes in the Church
Now shaking
Now shivering
Flanked by aged pillars of flesh
Now rising
Now shrieking
The Host unmoving
All approving
Now tearing
Now rending
Your robes descending
"O my Jesus, forgive us our sins, save us from the fires of hell"
Now burning
Now writhing
Our seats aflame
"O my Jesus"
"O my Jesus"
Save us from the fires of this ecstasy
"Forgive us our sins"
We cannot undo them
Save us from the fires of this ecstasy
ora pro nobis peccatoribus
now and at the hour of our death
Tuesday, 23 October 2018
Saturday, 8 August 2015
From love to Love
"God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us."
But the love the thirteenth apostle spoke of (a love that in order to count for anything in death, had to first live) was betrayed by those later writers who made a mockery of this "demonstration" by having Jesus "ascend into the clouds" while his disciples stood gaping at love raised to the level of an abstraction. The whole world was left to love Love.
Monday, 6 July 2015
The birth of natural religion
Many of these religious traditions are quite ancient. Even though they presume to be divinely guided, the recipients of revelation, witnesses of miracles, etc., the only evidence they have is the testimony of others, passed on from generation to generation, and anecdotal stories that seem to support their assumptions.
What if starting today you choose to set aside the old traditions about deities and spirits, and look at the world with these beliefs bracketed or unassumed? Would the gods or God make an appearance at all? Without your former presuppositions, would you find even a hint of the old gods in the world around you?
This is a challenge to those who have received their beliefs from others. What do you see if you use your own eyes?
Friday, 1 May 2015
Against the Christian nihilist
Recently a friend challenged me thus: "Do you not act inconsistently, or not understand the full implications of atheism, when you fail to appreciate the import of a life that has no meaning, that will cease to be forever, whose works will all come to naught? It seems to me that atheists should be a much more despairing group of people."
This, as I have mentioned elsewhere, is a very religious understanding of atheism. It already takes God as its starting point, a ground from which to make comparisons. For believers in God atheism is a negative, a subtraction. For non-believers it is no such thing, for there is nothing to subtract their perspective from. One must already have the existence of a God in order for his non-existence to draw the meaning of life away. For this reason one should be careful to see through the supposed argument to its root, what the interrogator is really saying: "I can't imagine life without God. My life would have no meaning without God, therefore yours shouldn't either." But this says little more than for this one, God has meaning. I can accept the first part of this argument, but not the second. I find it strange that a Christian would try to convince me life is meaningless because I do not believe in eternal life or a deity. In essence they are trying to convince me my hermeneutic of death is mistaken and that a proper atheist interpretation would see death as a meaning-vacuum, or a meaning-destroyer, and thus my life should consistently reflect the implications of this meaninglessness, i.e. I should hold a nihilistic attitude toward life. Fundamentally then we see the idea of God simultaneously sets up the possibility of a thoroughgoing nihilism.
Regarding death, even a cursory glance at the writings of antiquity reveals alternative views to the one held by my skeptical friend. For example, Lucretius: "Do you not know that in real death there will be no second you, living to lament your death and standing by your corpse?" From Seneca: "Life itself is neither a good nor an evil: life is where good or evil find a place, depending on how you make it for them." And from Montaigne (in the guise of Nature): "Truly imagine how much less bearable for Man, and how much more painful, would be a life which lasted for ever rather than the life which I have given you. If you did not have death you would curse me, for ever, for depriving you of it."
Why must I view death in the morose and nihilistic way my friend was convinced I should see it? Why not rather "eat and drink, for tomorrow we die" (St. Paul)? What I know is that I live. I have this life right before me. My friend, however, does not have even this evidence in support of her beliefs and ideas. If there is inconsistency, surely it lies with the notions of a God or eternal life, things that cannot be found anywhere in the world or nature, but merely as two of many ideas regarding supernatural matters. One might add, why are there not more Christians taking out full page ads in the paper, paying for multiple blocks of radio and television time, to warn people of eternal hell (no matter how the host of its cultured defenders would like to interpret it)? Perhaps the charge of inconsistency could function here as a mirror into which my friend should gaze intently, and with care.
Friday, 17 April 2015
Seeing
“What,” it will be Questioned, “When the Sun rises, do you not see a round Disk of fire somewhat like a Guinea?” O no no, I see an Innumerable company of the Heavenly host crying “Holy Holy Holy is the Lord God Almighty.” -Blake
what do you see
when this vast panoply
opens up before you?
guinea in the sun
host around the Son
there's a clue here
a key to the Real
Thursday, 4 September 2014
Meaning without God
As an atheist I've been asked how life can have ultimate meaning without God. This is quite a common question. For some of my nonfaith affiliated readers this will seem like a truly bizarre question. Does it suggest that people without faith lead meaningless lives, or at the very least, are simply fooling themselves about the things they find meaningful? The obvious answer is no, of course nonbelievers lead meaningful and fulfilling lives. Whether they're fooling themselves or not is really beside the point because you'd have to have a true ground of meaning outside the individual in order to compare. The question secretly sneaks God back into the equation for that reason. The atheist believes we create and sustain our own meaning (or the cultural/social meaning we take as our own from our context or the contexts of others). This meaning is tested by experience and reason, shared and shaped by the vicissitudes of life and time.
If believers would take a moment to reflect they'd see they're in a similar situation. When they feel that God ultimately guarantees the meaning of life or whatever, they too are dealing with an idea (no less culturally/socially mediated in most cases). So when they say that God guarantees meaning, the hidden supplement (that indeed must remain hidden) is that the idea of God guarantees meaning. It must have this meaning because believers have no more access to this supposed ground than anyone else. Indeed they take it on faith. The difference between the believer and the unbeliever is that the believer insists his idea has the status of a real object-person whereas the unbeliever recognises her values for what they are, i.e idea(l)s, and may or may not choose to argue why such idea(l)s are reasonable considering X. The believer can also argue about the reasonableness of his position but he has already made the categorical error of confusing idea with object, potential with actual, when really he's in the same boat as the rest of us.
For this reason the question "How can you have ultimate meaning without God" is illegitimate. It's force is only felt by the one who has already made his idea a god.
Thursday, 10 April 2014
Wednesday, 26 March 2014
Depression
What was the true beginning of this sum of events, this depressive condition? Was it the shock of discovering death in place of my loving grandfather? Was it the failure of a God I was led to believe could not fail, answered prayer, possessed omnipotence and so could act on His love for me, and so a discovery that death, or rather absence, stood also in the place of my God? Was it my inability to revive a still warm body before me? Was it the sound and feel of breaking bones during CPR? Was it the taste of his mouth, the smell of his breath, and the sound of air escaping his lungs? Was it the watch that dispassionately counted off the seconds even though its master could wind it no longer? Was it the solitude of the aftermath, the walk through a living forest which was also under time's injunction? It was of course the sum of these things.. and yet, except for perhaps this last which receives its power from the others, any one of them by themselves would have been enough. So it may be the relationship of one to the other adds significance to these individual events and so to the sum.
The "sum" doesn't end with these events.. it is something one can calculate at any moment, but always a present moment. Do we carry these things about like Sisyphus? At what point can we release them and gaze at the valley below? Perhaps the promise of a hilltop ensured that Sisyphus would continue to struggle. Even after he realized there was no rest at the top, that he was doomed forever to bear his load to the heights, he did not let his weight slide instantly away to the bottom but continued to push the cursed rock. Why didn't he simply let go? I think the answer must be that it had nothing to do with rocks.
Thursday, 6 March 2014
Lord Krishna incarnation of Vishnu
Nay, and of hearts which follow other gods
In simple faith, their prayers arise to me,
O Kunti's Son! though they pray wrongfully;
For I am the Receiver and the Lord
Of every sacrifice, which these know not
Rightfully; so they fall to earth again!
Who follow gods go to their gods; who vow
Their souls to demi-gods go to demi-gods; minds
To spirits and ghosts given o'er sink to such things;
And whoso loveth Me cometh to Me.
Whoso shall offer Me in faith and love
A leaf, a flower, a fruit, water poured forth,
That offering I accept, lovingly made
With pious will. Whate'er thou doest, Prince!
Eating or sacrificing, giving gifts,
Praying or fasting, let it all be done
For Me, as Mine. So shalt thou free thyself
From Karmabandh, the chain which holdeth men
To good and evil issue, so shalt come
Safe unto Me- when thou art quit of flesh-
By faith and abdication joined to Me!
I am alike for all! I know not hate,
I know not favour! What is made is Mine!
But them that worship Me with love, I love;
They are in Me, and I a friend to them!
Bhagavad Gita, 9
Monday, 16 September 2013
Derrida on Negative Theology
Sauf le nom
Friday, 13 September 2013
Sam Harris contra Theism
(He doesn't demolish it.. but he puts a dent in it with the help of some older critiques)
Update: We're down to 6.6 million under the age of 5 deaths per year now, or 18,000 deaths a day UNICEF/WHO.
Sunday, 25 August 2013
On God
The starting point of our theological investigation is not whether there is a definitive proof for the existence of God (there can be no such empirical proof), but allowing that God exists, what can be definitively said about such a being. We find, apart from the formal and thoroughly socialized subjective fantasies and wishful thinking of a great many people, that there isn't a hell of a lot. We find the god of the churches almost undeniably does not exist. This has been realized in the West for almost 300 years, and this by theologians themselves! Where it hasn't been realized one continues to find the most powerful illusion at work, propagated by laypeople and theological upstarts, pastors and other parasitical people of "good intention" (at least initially), not to mention a programme of systemic indoctrination in the form of emotive collective music, sermons, and what amounts to religious self-help literature.
The strongest "proof" this God doesn't exist: He hasn't saved the Christians from Christianity.
Saturday, 24 August 2013
Father God
Thursday, 11 July 2013
In my boyhood days -Hölderlin
In my boyhood days
Often a god would save me
From the shouts and from the rods of men;
Safe and good then I played
With the orchard flowers
And the breezes of heaven
Played with me.
And as you make glad
The hearts of the plants
When toward you they stretch
Their delicate arms.
So you made glad my heart,
Father Helios, and like Endymion
I was your darling,
Holy Luna.
O all you loyal,
Kindly gods!
Would that you knew how
My soul loved you then.
True, at that time I did not
Evoke you by name yet, and you
Never named me, as men use names,
As though they knew one another.
Yet I knew you better
Than ever I have known men,
I understood the silence of Aether,
But human words I´ve never understood.
I was reared by the euphony
Of the rustling copse
And learned to love
Amid the flowers.
I grew up in the arms of the gods.
Monday, 3 June 2013
Transcendental
Tuesday, 21 May 2013
Out of the whirlwind
As the death toll from the recent tornado in Oklahoma mounts, Facebook and newsfeeds are full of prayers for the victims and their families. Meanwhile insurance companies and emergency services are designating this tragedy as an act of God. The irony should not be lost on anyone.
What view of God should one have? God is obviously hidden from us, unwilling or unable to fulfill his obligations or answer the prayers of those who call on him. This God is obscure. This God is the Hidden God. I will not say this is the dead God, though in many ways he might as well be. I will merely say here that he is hidden, as are God's ways. One should challenge those who say otherwise as hypocrites and deceivers, or at least, wishful thinkers. They are obviously not interested in the Real, or are plainly deceived. I recently spoke with a pastor who wondered at the loss of youth from his community. I did not wonder. No program or worship service will bring them back or attract more. People are drawn to authenticity that corresponds with experience and what we know of the world. Church has always adapted to its cultural surroundings and will continue to do so. But today a radical change is needed. People of faith will make it. Cowards and hypocrites will praise God.
Wednesday, 27 March 2013
The logic of Sacrifice (A letter)
Thursday, 10 March 2011
Trinity and Politics (Kathryn Tanner)

I attended a lecture last night entitled: "The Trinity & Politics: Is the Trinity Really the Best Guide to the Proper Way to Live Together?" given by Yale Divinity School professor Kathryn E. Tanner. In a nutshell her argument was that Trinitarian relational models are fraught with complications due not only to certain ambiguities concerning the relations of the Trinity, but the ability to interpret Trinitarian relations along similar lines of more monotheistic models, i.e. hierarchical, patriarchal, non-individualistic (in the sense that personal identities are often blurred), subordinationist, etc. She is certainly correct about this and I agree that Trinitarian models have been over-hyped.
What then should the model be? Well one potential model is Christ himself, who as the God-man, is the exemplar of human-Trinitarian relations, not just immanently, but economically, i.e. not just between the persons of the Trinity itself, but between God and humans. How should Christians relate to one another and the Other? Not by using the Trinity as a guide to living interpersonally, but by looking to Christ in his relations to the Father and the Spirit, and in his relations to other people.
Afterwards I had the privilege to speak with Dr. Tanner regarding her lecture. Let's move away from this Trinitarian morass in favour of another model, yes. But my claim is not that Jesus is the better option here, but a more radical one. Jesus as an exemplar is itself fraught with ambiguities and pitfalls. I asked Kathryn if her version of Christ isn’t in fact an idealized one. What of those scriptures where Jesus obviously discriminates against others (it is only the woman’s faith in him that surprises Jesus, whereas her initial appeal for help was ignored) Matt. 15?
Not only, I argue, is her Jesus idealized, it doesn't take into account the impossibility of using Jesus as a model. Jesus may be human, but he is also, as the 2nd person of the Trinity, intrinsically different than other human beings. Yes he is fully human! But he is simultaneously something quite different. Wasn’t this Watt’s critique, that Jesus, as the unique son of God, is in a very different position than the rest of humanity and so had an advantage, even if this advantage was practically denied by Jesus? The difference is that while Jesus may have denied his divinity (kenotic movement etc) and became a wretched human (weak, mortal etc), unlike other humans he had the ability to divest himself of divinity in the first place. There will always be a minimal gap between Jesus and other humans no matter how much like the poorest of them he became (and this without taking the miracles into account).
The radical move would have been to leave aside not only the Trinity, but Jesus as well. What Christians need is not an already impossible model, an idealized God-man, but a model who can have no special claims to divinity, who is intrinsically like us, who models in his/her life a radical fidelity lived out in the field of social relations.


